February 28, 2017
Jaime French was jarred out of bed in Emerson, Manitoba early one morning this month by pounding at her front door, just yards from the U.S. border. A face peered in through the window, flanked in the darkness by others.
Outside were 16 illegal immigrants, arriving at one of the first houses they saw after crossing a lightly monitored border between Canada and the United States.
“They banged pretty hard, then ‘ring ring ring’ the doorbell,” said French, a mother of two young girls. “It was scary. That really woke me up.”
The town has become the front line of an emerging political crisis that is testing Canada’s will to welcome asylum seekers.
Hundreds of people, mainly from Africa but also the Middle East, are fleeing President Donald Trump’s crackdown on illegal immigrants, refugee agencies say. Many asylum seekers say Trump’s election and subsequent crackdown on illegal immigrants spurred their plans to head north.
Those arriving in Emerson come on foot in the dead of night, unnerving its 650 residents. Some fear the influx of unscreened immigrants while others are frustrated by the cost and effort forced on the community.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is under increased pressure from the left, which wants him to let more in, and from the right, which is fearful of an increased security risk. Trudeau must tread carefully to ensure the issue does not complicate relations with Trump.
The cooling welcome in Emerson is a microcosm of growing discontent over Canada’s open door policy for refugees.
Last week, an Angus Reid poll found that while 47 percent of respondents said Canada is taking in the right number of refugees, 41 percent said the number is already too high.
“It could become a real political liability for the government,” said Christian Leuprecht, a politics professor at the Royal Military College of Canada, noting that spring will lead to even more crossings as travel gets easier.
THAWING OUT IN THE KITCHEN
After the 16 illegal immigrants left French’s home, without being admitted, they found truck driver Brad Renout two doors down leaving for work.
“I was going to leave them all outside,” Renout said. “I figured, to hell with (them) for coming over the border in winter.”
When he saw children among the group, Renout allowed three women, three toddlers and two teenagers into his kitchen.
Early Sunday, Reuters witnessed at least seven illegal immigrants bundled in new parkas and bulging backpacks walking into Canada from Minnesota, following railway tracks in the icy dark.
Ismail, a 25-year-old Somali man, said they had walked for 22 hours without sleep across North Dakota. As police lights flashed distantly, Ismail said he was afraid to walk toward them.
He thought the group was still on U.S. soil.
Canadian police caught up with them shortly afterward and arrested them for illegally entering Canada. The group squeezed, uncuffed, into a police minivan and headed to a government office for questioning.
“We feel sorry for the people,” said retired grain farmer Ken Schwark. “I just wish they would come through the legal way.”
A 2004 agreement between Canada and the United States means asylum seekers must submit applications in the United States if they arrive there first. But if they find a way into Canada, they can apply for refugee status there.
It’s an avenue that has spurred north illegal immigrants in the United States, especially Somalis settled in Minnesota, which shares a land border with Manitoba. After pricey taxi rides to North Dakota, many like Ismail walk for hours in darkness and -4°F temperatures to dimly lit Emerson, in the shadow of the bright glare of the international border crossing.
The lucky immigrants get rides dropping them off less than a mile from Noyes, Minnesota, within sight of Emerson’s southern edge. From there they duck under a metal crossing-arm gate, walk across the border and often use their own cellphones to dial police.
Others are dropped 19 miles or more from the border, and follow rail lines into Emerson, crossing a border marked in most areas only by scattered concrete boundary markers.
Faye Suderman, a four-decade Emerson resident, said she is sympathetic but draws a line between those fleeing persecution and those who have simply run out of chances in the United States: “How difficult is it to get rid of those people and give help to those truly in need?”
Emerson Cafe manager Jacquelyn Reimer, who has fed shivering asylum seekers for free, wondered why the Canadian government is helping refugees when the country has its own homeless problem. “We can’t even take care of our own,” she said.
MAKESHIFT BEDS, NUTELLA SANDWICHES
Due to its border-hugging location, Emerson’s encounters with migrants are not new, but the scale of their arrivals is.
In the first two months of 2017, 143 mainly Somali people walked illegally over the border into Emerson, representing 40 percent of Manitoba’s full-year total in 2015/16. Quebec and British Columbia are the two other major illegal crossing points, but police there refused to provide data.
Emerson residents don’t encounter the migrants for long before police arrive and whisk them to the local Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) office for questioning. From there, they are ferried to Winnipeg, Manitoba’s capital, to file asylum claims.
Despite some residents’ fears, asylum-seekers have not caused any trouble, said Bill Spanjer, Emerson’s emergency coordinator.
“They’re going to be on their best behavior because otherwise their refugee claim is certainly going to be affected,” he said.
When police receive a call, they summon the town’s volunteer firefighters to treat any health concerns, as the nearest ambulance is 25 minutes away. In December, two men from Ghana lost all of their fingers to frostbite.
Firefighter callouts cost Emerson about $500 each time. The costs may add up to $30,000 since last spring, representing 10 percent of its firefighting budget, said Emerson-Franklin’s elected leader Greg Janzen. The provincial government directed more resources to Emerson last week, including paramedics and paralegal and transportation services.
Since the influx sped up in January, the strain on Emerson has grown. In early February, police intercepted 18 illegal immigrants from Somalia and Djibouti and CBSA asked Emerson to temporarily house them in the town’s ice rink.
Brenda Piett and other volunteers laid folding banquet tables on the concrete floor, and layered them with blankets for makeshift mattresses. At the immigrants’ request, they served white bread sandwiches with Nutella hazelnut spread.
“The groups are getting bigger, and the stories are scary, how far they’ve walked,” said Piett, an inventory clerk at Emerson’s duty-free store. “But it does affect our town. Some people are very scared of it.”